Sri Ramanuja Munaye Namaha,
Sri Velukkudi Krishnan Swmai Guruve Namaha,
Dear Vikram BhagavAta,
Adiyen believe, BhagavAtA is reading with pre-conceived mind considering other mathams are isolated mathams and all are doing wrong.
Swami has said, we should draw a line looking at GUNAS (BEHAVIOUR), Good Behavior or Bad Behavior is what is prescribed by BhagavAn (Shastra’s means Do’s & Don’ts). Are all the Hindus behaving good. If so, why do we need Acharyas avatram & Swami Ramanuajr Avataram irrespective of Moksham. Swami Ramanuajar is mainly called asr “SriRangatthai Thirutthi Vaitton Vazhiye (one who corrected SriRangam and said Moksham is for everyone who has Aasai, not just for 1st varnas as per Shastras)”. A Brahman SriVaishnavite put poison on Swami’s Uccha Vritti Annam due to Jealousy (Bad behavior). So can we blindly say, Sri Vaishavaites are Good. No correct. SO, base line Behavior is important and then Devotion. Swami has said, one by wearing Symbols on their forehead doesn’t become a Sri Vaishanavite, if by MInner MIND they don’t have Karunai towards other living beings and devoation to GOD, and isolate from bad entities.
In India, majority are Hindus by Birth Certificate and spread everywhere. Consider the Jail in India, if we take census of the religion by certificate, majority of them will be Hindus, does it mean Hinduism taught them to do bad. No correct, that is because, they did not follow the Behavioral Rules as per Hinduism, and so they are in Jail, irrespective of their Birth Certificate as Hindu. Same situation for other country like usa, where, majority of them inside the Jail are Christians, doesn’t means their matham taught them to be bad. They just did not follow their ethical behavior own texts.
So, the question is not about Hindu, christian or muslim it is about their base text in their own religion teaches Ethical Things, which is not being followed by everyone in each of their religion. Does BhagavAta understand this point. Same as the Swami’s Enpani. Why Swami talks about Sri VAIshanava Lakshanam etc….. it means many of us don’t follow, so we have to follow it. If we all follow initially, then why Swami had to waste time teaching us all these.
So, every Matham has dilution due to the bad behavior people inside that Matham’s who doesn’t follow their own Ethical text. Like Ravan is a Brahman and followed Vedas, chanted Mantras and great devotee of Shiva Devata. But he was destructive to the world. Does it means Vedas taught him to do bad. Can we make judgement that Hindusim is bad. No correct. It is not about the spiritual text, since any religion text always teaches good things for everyone., but some doesn’t follow it for the Welfare of everyone, and if that person is influential, then he can bring destruction to the world, like Ravan etc…
So now each Mathams are following their own text and for the welfare of others.
That’s what adiyen was saying above, the core Christians are following their Ethical Text and propagating for welfare of others. Adiyen not sure, if BhagavAtas friends are core ethical followers of their own texts or not. So, they will tell what they know. If we are following our own Hinduism spiritual texts and apply for welfare of others, then we can say, “NO Thank you for your Pamphlet, I’m already following the Ethical conduct and faith on GOD through my faith that GOD has given me birth”.
Acharyas “Pira Matha Kandanam” was due to false propagation of bad influential persons distorting the good faith followers. It is not aimed at the Good behavior of people, it is aimed at the bad own developed Philosophy of the people which was destructive for mankind and against GOD’s mind.
If one is following a good philosophy/behavior, then we have no rights to condemn others, let it be any religion.
In India, the “Dry Knowledge” Spiritualists (without Karunai/Sneham) was more in olden days who misused Vedas for self fish reasons, and there were Temple atrocities (bad behavior) in the name of GOD following, when GOD himself has not enacted anything like that in Texts. So, GOD closes such Temples and destroys such bad behavior Vedic people. This is same applicable for other religions, when they don’t follow their own Ethical texts.
So, it all about GOOD Behavior with faith in GOD, let it be any religion. So malicious behavior that is seen in any religion is condemnable, so BhagavAta need not to get into details of differences within other religion, since every religion has its own issues due to people not following their own texts. That’s why GOD sends Spiritual Masters in each area to straighten or sort of the issues to channelize the path for Spirituality and Moksham.
That’s why adiyen said in previous thread,
So the Primary thing that we should focus in This Kali Yuga is “HOW TO BE A GOOD PERSON“, A good person who has faith in GOD in any religion is better than a Bad person in any religion. Let BhagavAn take care who should reach Moksham through which religion, and let’s only follow, the PATH that what BhagavAn has chosen for us in a view point that other Jeevaathmas of any religion should also reach Moksham in SAME BIRTH and pray on our Guru’s lotus feet, whenever our Gyanam raises a bit.
Also Swami gas said that BhagavAn has a beautiful KALYANA GUNAM “NiraANKUSA SWATHANTRIYAM / நிராங்குச ஸ்வாதந்த்ரியம் (Non-questionable Independence) which BhagavAn utilizes to give Salvation/Moksham or anything to anyone irrespective of their religion, varna or state of mind. So we ignorant Bhaddhatmas cannot make Judegemt or Conclusion that it will take long time for someone and short time for someone else and who should get Moksham and question how BhagavAn gave Moksham to Shishupalan or Dhadhipandan or Naalooran or Gantakaranans brother etc…That’s why BhagavAn doesn’t even say everything to us about whom and all HE gives Moksham, since we have habit of questioning BhagavAn’s actions. It’s up to BhagavAn on how to handle/deal with his properties (we Jeevathmas) because all Jeevathmas are HIS property and NOT our property.
Adiyen Sri Velukkudi Krishna Dasan,
Uyya Oraey Vazhi UdayavAr ThiruvAdi,
Sarvam SriKRishnarpanam Asthu