ஸ்ரீமதே ரங்கரமனுஜ மஹாதேசிகாய நம:
ஸ்ரீமதே ஸ்ரீ வராஹ மஹாதேசிகாய நம:
ஸ்ரீ வேளுக்குடி கிருஷ்ணன் ஸ்வாமி திருவடிகளே சரணம்
பதில் பிடி பட வில்லை. குற்றத்தின் தன்மை பொறுத்து குற்றமா ?
Srimathe Ramanujaya Namaha,
In enpani 1519, Swami didnot mean the Abduction of Sita Piratti is not a crime. What Swami was saying is,
Both cases of Vali and Ravana are realted to WOMEN ABUSES, and both attracts law and punishment, but the penalties vary for each case due to the severity of the felony.
In Vali’s case, he already committed the severe crime.
1) Vali beat his brother Sugreeva near to death and Sugreeva ran away to save his life, then
2) Vali snatched Sugreeva’s wife and committed Women Assault.
These are very serious crimes and moreover Vali was not in a position to accept his crime or any kind of discussion. So Vali’s behaviour is like a Anarchist, and in such cases The Law Enforcement people just take action in earliest opportunity without negotiation. Hence, under these circumstances, there is no necessity for any talks with the accused person like Vali, so SriRma A kSathriya The ONLY King, just took him down with now and arrow from behind the bushes without any prior notice. So Case is closed. This is what Swami meant in enpani that “Vali Kuttram Seidhu Vittaan, adhanaal Dhandanai kudukka pattadhu”
In Ravanan case, he also committed the crime, but it was “Women Abduction” without any further serious felonies like “Women Assault” committed by Vali. This is what Swami meant in enpani as “Ravan innum Kuttram Seyya villai (means the Crime of Ravan was not as serious as Vali’s crime and Swami didnot mean to say Ravana didn’t commit crime).
So there was punishment for Ravan due to Abduction of Sita Piratti and the punishment for Ravana was not same level as Vali due to intensity of crime being different. SriRama gave him chance to return Sita Piratti many times till end of the battle, but at the end, SriRama punished (killed) Ravana since he was not submissive of his crime.
So, What Swami meant is, both Vali and Ravana did crimes, but Penalties/Punishment were different for both due to the severity of felony being different.
This is what Adiyen understood from Swami’s enpani 1512.
Adiyen Srinivasa (DhoddayAcharyar) Dasan.
Srimathe Rangaramanuja Mahadesikaya Namaha
Srimathe SriVarAha MahAdEsikAya Namaha
Sri Velukkudi Krishnan Swamy Thiruvadigaley Sharanam
First of all Adiyen would like to thank my Swamy for giving me freedom to have counter view and letting adiyen think.
With Velukkudi Krishnan Swamy thirivadi bhalam adiyen got one more answer
This is the reason for the difference in treatment